Redgrass Everlasting Palette XL vs Army Painter Wet Palette

The Redgrass Everlasting XL is the better palette for painters who paint regularly. The tighter lid seal keeps paint workable overnight, the calibrated sponge maintains consistent hydration, and the XL surface fits a full session palette without crowding. The Army Painter palette is the right starting point for painters who want to try wet palette painting before committing to a premium option.

This comparison contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and partner of other programs, BrushBench may earn a commission at no cost to you.

At a glance

Spec	Redgrass Games Everlasting Wet Palette Painter XL Check price on Amazon	Army Painter Wet Palette Starter Set Check price on Amazon
Price	$35-$48	$18-$28
Our rating	4.7 / 5	4.2 / 5
Best for	Any painter who blends or works in extended sessions and wants paint to stay workable for hours.	Painters who want to try a wet palette before committing to a premium option.
Seal quality	Tight, overnight paint retention	Adequate, less airtight
Surface size	XL, full session palette	Smaller, limited colour spread
Sponge	Calibrated, consistent hydration	Standard, needs more monitoring
Price	$35-$48	$18-$28

The two options in depth

4.7 Amazon

Redgrass Games Everlasting Wet Palette Painter XL

The benchmark wet palette for miniature painters, with a calibrated hydration sponge, quality semi-permeable paper, and a sealing lid that keeps paint workable for days.

Best for Any painter who blends or works in extended sessions and wants paint to stay workable for hours.

Tightly sealing lid keeps paint fresh overnight and across multiple sessionsXL size provides ample space for a full painting session paletteWell-calibrated sponge maintains consistent hydration without over-saturating Replacement paper is a recurring cost

$35-$48 Check price on Amazon

4.2 Amazon

Army Painter Wet Palette Starter Set

Budget-entry wet palette from Army Painter bundled with palette paper refills and sponge, a practical low-cost entry point to wet palette painting.

Best for Painters who want to try a wet palette before committing to a premium option.

Low entry price with consumables includedPalette paper is thinner and more permeable than DIY parchmentArmy Painter brand means replacement paper is widely available Lid seal is less airtight than the Redgrass palette

$18-$28 Check price on Amazon

Which should you buy?

Buy the Redgrass Everlasting XL if you paint more than once a week and want the palette to work without constant sponge monitoring. Buy the Army Painter palette if you are trying wet palette painting for the first time and want a low-cost entry before deciding to commit. Most painters who start on the Army Painter eventually upgrade to the Redgrass.

Common questions

Does the Redgrass Everlasting truly keep paint overnight?

Yes, when the lid is fully sealed and the sponge is properly saturated. Standard acrylics stay workable overnight and often into the following day. After 48 to 72 hours even the Redgrass seal lets enough moisture escape that paint quality degrades. The Army Painter palette shows drying faster, often within a few hours if not sealed perfectly.

Do both use the same replacement paper?

No. Each brand sells its own replacement paper formulated for its specific palette. Redgrass paper is thinner and more permeable; Army Painter paper is slightly thicker. You can use third-party paper in either palette but results vary. Both brands sell refill packs that work reliably with their own palette.